A Road…By Any Other Name

Shakespeare’s Juliet asks: “What’s in a name” as she and Romeo anguish over the feud between their respective families, the Montagues and Capulets, that forbids their love and ultimately dooms them both.

Surely no such dilemma for Hambledon as it seeks an appropriate name for the approach road into the small development of affordable homes being built at what was once Orchard Farm? You would think not.

However, while not carrying the consequences of Shakespeare’s tragedy, it has proved to be surprisingly difficult to find a name that accords with borough council street naming policy and meets village expectations. But progress is being made.

This website carried a report highlighting that, as construction of the seven affordable and two open-market properties gets under way, the developer English Rural is required to put forward a suitable name options to Waverley Borough Council which makes the final decision.

English Rural was proposing naming it Tillson Gardens, after a respected executive of the housing association who had recently died. Hambledon Parish Council felt this was not an appropriate choice as the name had no connection to the village. Guidelines state that names of people alive or recently deceased should be avoided and best practice was for the developer to consult with the local parish council and, where possible, that the name should reflect local significance or historic links.

After consulting around the village, all those who commented supported the approach of the parish council and most suggested a name containing the word Orchard in recognition of its previous name.

This is where matters became tricky. Orchard, regardless of the suffix, was not suitable because it was too common and, with several other similarly-named roads in the locality, it could lead to confusion. The access to the site is on the A283 Wormley Hill, but Hill was also rejected for the same reason.

Other names came…and went. Given the previous use of Orchard Farms as a stables and livery yard, Stable was suggested. Again, too many others.

Jane Woolley, former Hambledon Parish Council clerk and a custodian of much of our village archive, visited the Surrey History Centre on Woking and unearthed some fascinating background. She discovered that the Orchard Farm field had once belonged to the family of the noted Victorian amateur entomologist James John Joicey. He travelled the world collecting butterflies and other insects and added greatly to the understanding of Lepidoptera. It is estimated he collected 1.5 million specimens, the second largest in the world, according to his Wikipedia entry.

The family lived at the now-demolished house The Hill, which was on top of Wormley Hill and just outside our parish. There James Joicey established a museum housing much of his collection. The Orchard Farm site, inside Hambledon parish, was used as a kitchen garden and contained a wooden building used as annex for more of his specimen. Much of his collection is now at The Natural History Museum.

The name Joicey was put to the Waverley Addressing Team, but it was concerned that the name would be mis-spelt. The policy is to have distinct as well as un-duplicated names to reduce confusion for emergency services.

The Joicey family hailed originally from the North East of England where they were wealthy coal mine owners. Parish Council inquiries revealed that in Gateshead area alone there are ten roads named after Joicey. If they can cope with ten in Gateshead, who not one in Hambledon?

Stewart Payne, on behalf of Hambledon Parish Council, contacted the Waverley Addressing Team after first ascertaining that English Rural, which must submit the name, was more than happy with the name Joicey.

The strong links with the Orchard Farm site were explained as was the desire of villagers to have a name that celebrated a local personage. It seemed to tick all the boxes

Waverley has agreed to put the name forward as our first choice and we await a positive development.

 

 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Stephen maycock
Stephen maycock
3 years ago

Well done Jane. Excellent suggestion.

Paul
Paul
3 years ago

So we’re naming the road after a coal mining magnate from ‘Oop North’ who was given all his money by his family and never did a days work in his life whilst many of the thousands of men, women and boys working for him died in horrific working conditions in his coal mines? The death rate was highest in boys (putters) effectively working as child slave labour in the coal mines. He was reportedly the biggest owner of coal in the country yet despite his inherited wealth James Joicey managed to go bankrupt numerous times. When sued by creditors in… Read more »

Jon Petersen
Jon Petersen
3 years ago
Reply to  Paul

I’m with Paul on this, from what I’ve read about Joicey we shouldn’t be naming a road after him.

Mary
Mary
3 years ago

Whilst very much appreciating Jane’s research I too am against naming after Joicey for exactly the same reasons, and as he effectively destroyed so many (hopefully orchid collecting was better!) I do hope butterfly isn’t incorporated in the name!
‘The naming of roads is a difficult matter, it isn’t just one of your holiday games..’

Stewart Payne
Stewart Payne
3 years ago
Reply to  Mary

I think the concerns over the Joicey name are legitimate. But what instead? That is the problem for the parish council as it tries to find a name that is acceptable under the many and varied rules and policies of Waverley, while meeting with village expectations. Policy states that a name should reflect past/historic connections to the site, but when we offered Orchard, this was refused by Waverley because too many similar names. Hill, Stables etc fate with a similar fate, hence going further back in history. It appears unlikely that Waverley will accept Joicey and I have no personal… Read more »

Jon Petersen
Jon Petersen
3 years ago
Reply to  Stewart Payne

A bit dull, but how about something like “Wormley Park”. Although in Hambledon, the area lies between Wormley and Hambledon Park and is bounded on two sides by Wormley Lane. A quick search didn’t throw up any other use of this name.

Lindsay
Lindsay
3 years ago
Reply to  Jon Petersen

I think dull is the right choice given all the restrictions. The development is in Wormley rather than Hambledon and so an appropriate suggestion.

Or perhaps Clay Lane/Road/Park as there are currently large mounds of clay on the site as proof of the relevance (!) and explains why all flora grows so well on the site and why it historically made a nice nursery.

Stewart Payne
Stewart Payne
3 years ago
Reply to  Lindsay

Thanks for the thoughts on a road name. The Orchard Farm site is within the parish of Hambledon, Wormley is within Witley parish, so this has to be taken into account when considering a name. Despite the site’s most recent name, it seems it never was an orchard, nor a farm, and not really a garden either. It was, as many villagers know, a stables and livery yard and, going back, a kitchen garden growing mainly vegetables. We are testing “Livery” with Waverley, but please keep the suggestions (sensible ones only please) coming.

Paul Smith
Paul Smith
3 years ago
Reply to  Stewart Payne

As both amusing and educational as the road naming epic has been it was becoming tiresome. However, with this fresh news I’m left invigorated! When I bought Orchard Farm it had a Wormley address according to the land register. The Royal Mail and various utility companies also agreed with this. Therefore are you now stating that this is wrong and I should have a Hambledon address? If this isn’t the case then you might be mistaken that all of Wormley is part of Witley Parish. Possibly parts of Wormley come under Hambledon Parish? If not then there is good news… Read more »

Stewart Payne
Stewart Payne
3 years ago
Reply to  Paul Smith

Tiresome for us as well Paul. I cannot comment on your postal/utilities address but the fact remains that the entire Orchard Farm site is within the legally defined boundary of the parish of Hambledon, and so is a Hambledon parish responsibility, as
are the affordable homes.

Deborah Cavalcante
Deborah Cavalcante
3 years ago
Reply to  Stewart Payne

Embracing its equestrian history, how about “Paddock Place”?